Help Us Stay Paywall-Free

We rely on readers to keep our website open to all. Help sustain a public space for collective reasoning and imagination—make a tax-deductible donation today.

October 17, 2020

Our Constitutional Crisis

—and how our constitution stacks up against others around the world.

Since 1789, constitutions worldwide have come and gone. According to University of Chicago Law professor Tom Ginsburg, the median lifespan of a national constitution is eight years—which former Boston Review columnist and leading legal scholar Pamela Karlan has quipped is “roughly the life expectancy of a Great Dane.”

But the U.S. Constitution continues to limp on. Indeed, amendments to the Constitution are starting to gain traction amongst progressives, with the Electoral College, the distorted representation in the Senate, life tenure for federal judges, and a campaign finance system dominated by the rich topping their list of woes. But in a recent essay from emeritus Harvard Law professor Mark Tushnet, he argues that our constitutional crisis won’t be fixed by simply tackling a few isolated reforms. “If we are truly committed to revitalizing democracy,” he writes, “we must consider more thoroughgoing changes to constitutional design from the ground up.”

Formally a constitutional monarchy, Thailand is also amidst a crisis of its own. As Peera Songkünnatham explains in a new essay, the king’s insistence that he is above the constitution rather than bound by it has angered many Thai people and resulted in some of the largest protests the country has ever seen. We also look abroad to India in today’s reading list, with Ashutosh Varshney exploring how the country’s constitutional history suggests a framework for creating democracy in unlikely settings.

Lastly, two recent pieces argue that the U.S. Constitution has much further to go when it comes to protecting the rights of people of color and women respectively. In the former, Jefferson Cowie explores the history and persistence of what he terms the “Slaveholder’s Constitution” and how it led to a particularly white form of American “freedom”. And while Virginia recently became the crucial thirty-eighth state to ratify the Equal Rights Amendment, renewed efforts to quash it stand to wipe out a hundred years of women’s work as constitution-makers. “What does it say about the United States as a nation, and the Constitution as its law,” Yale law professor Julie Suk asks, “if it bars a constitutional amendment guaranteeing sex equality because of procedure?”

Mark Tushnet
Constitutional crisis won’t be fixed by a few isolated reforms. We need to rethink the Constitution from the ground up.
Peera Songkünnatham

Thailand has been gripped by the largest wave of protest in years, forcing a reckoning between the country’s dual structures of democracy and monarchy.

Julie C. Suk

This year Virginia became the crucial thirty-eighth state to ratify the ERA. Renewed efforts to quash it stand to wipe out a hundred years of women’s work as constitution-makers.

Ashutosh Varshney
Though Modi's government draws concern today, the country's constitutional history suggests a framework for creating democracy in unlikely settings. 
Pamela S. Karlan

The median lifespan of a national constitution is roughly the life expectancy of a Great Dane. Why has the U.S. Constitution endured?

William Hogeland

Public history should make us think.

Pamela S. Karlan

The Constitution assigns the job of carrying out its vision to all the branches of government, not just to the judiciary.

Jefferson Cowie

In a political season of dog whistles, we must be attentive to how talk of American freedom has long been connected to the presumed right of whites to dominate everyone else.

Our weekly themed Reading Lists compile the best of Boston Review’s archive. Sign up for our newsletters to get them straight to your inbox before they appear online.

Boston Review is nonprofit and reader funded.

We believe in the power of collective reasoning and imagination to create a more just world. That’s why we’re committed to keeping our website free and open to everyone, regardless of ability to pay. But we can’t do it without the financial support of our readers.

Help sustain a public space for collective reasoning and imagination, without ads or paywalls:

Become a supporting reader today.

Get Our Newsletter

Sign up to get vital reading on politics, literature, and more sent straight to your inbox.

Most Recent

How U.S. laws—branding Palestinians as “terrorists” and redefining anti-Semitism—serve Israel’s interests.

Maryam Jamshidi

Israel's weaponization of images since October 7 obfuscates its genocidal campaign against Palestinians.

Ariella Azoulay
Thad Williamson

Just in time for the holidays, get any three print issues of Boston Review for just $35 – that’s 40% off the cover price!

Before December 9, mix and match any three issues for one low price using code 3FOR35.

Just in time for the holidays, get any three print issues of Boston Review for just $35 – that’s 40% off the cover price!

Before December 9, mix and match any three issues for one low price using code 3FOR35.

"An indispensable pillar of the public sphere."

That’s what sociologist Alondra Nelson says of Boston Review. Independent and nonprofit, we believe in the power of collective reasoning and imagination to create a more just world.

That’s why there are no paywalls on our website, but we can’t do it without the support of our readers. Please make a tax-deductible donation to help us create a more inclusive and egalitarian public sphere—open to everyone, regardless of ability to pay.