Help Us Stay Paywall-Free

Democracy depends on the free exchange of ideas. Help sustain it with a tax-deductible donation today.

Mural on a brick wall—two clapping hands in a light blue circle
August 20, 2023

Making Hope Possible

On the utopian and dystopian tendencies of our current conjuncture.

From global warming and rising fascism to surveillance capitalism and deaths of despair, it’s hard not to feel that the world is hurtling toward dystopia. At the same time, advances in science and technology, militant youth activism on behalf of climate and social justice, and the global resurgence of egalitarian, social democratic politics offer genuine glimmers of hope: through concerted action, we can not only avert the worst but also set our sights on an emphatically utopian future.

According to Lynne Segal, it’s clear “why dystopian scenarios have become more seductive than ever”—who wouldn’t feel despair in the face of poverty, wars, pandemics, and a rapidly warming planet? Yet maintaining hope amidst today’s ubiquitous “dystopian imagination” is imperative, not least because “pessimism can dangerously align us with a form of reactionary conservatism.” Invoking Marxist cultural theorist Raymond Williams, Segal argues that it is the job of today’s activists and organizers to “make hope possible rather than despair convincing.” To do so, they must emphasize the “pleasure of acting in concert to assert our need for each other and our natural world.”

The novels of Kim Stanley Robinson are another place to find such “resources of hope,” argues Dayton Martindale in his panoramic review of Three Californias, Robinson’s speculative trilogy about possible dystopian and utopian futures. Published in the 1980s and 90s, the novels abound in “moments of real prescience: each book foresees some crucial aspect of America” in the early twenty-first century, providing “helpful tools with which to examine our present.” While “utopias are no substitute for other forms of political action,” Martindale concedes, “they can help orient us toward what we are trying to build.” Especially when it comes to global warming, Robinson’s fictions “offer genuine guidance to the contemporary left, worth mining for ideas as we envision and fight for a Green New Deal.”

Other contributions to this week’s list consider the utopian and dystopian tendencies of our current conjuncture while reflecting on the meaning of these two fundamental categories of modern experience. Matthew Cole tracks the dystopian drift of technocratic ideals and explains their threat to democracy; Christine Sypnowich draws inspiration from the utopian artist and author William Morris to argue for a world of equal flourishing; Sarah Hill asks hard questions about the model Spanish village of Marinaleda, offering reflections on the original utopian, Sir Thomas More, along the way; Junot Díaz interviews Margaret Atwood about The Handmaid’s Tale; Peter Ross examines the legacy of George Orwell; Ian Maxton describes a world beyond traditional notions of time and authorship; Nate File explores the aesthetics and politics of Afrofuturism; and more.

Rereleased this year in a single volume, Kim Stanley Robinson’s trilogy Three Californias imagines three possible futures for the world writ large through the lens of Orange County, California.

Dayton Martindale

Dependence is a fact of all our lives; freedom lies in our capacity to care for others.

Lynne Segal

Spain's Marinaleda appears to possess all the elements of a radical dream come true. Is it for real?

Sarah Hill
 
Nate File

Democratic theory points to two problems: unjust concentrations of power and a flawed theory of knowledge.

Matthew Cole

Junot Díaz interviews Margaret Atwood about The Handmaid's Tale, political dystopias, and Drake.

Margaret Atwood, Junot Díaz

From invading Afghanistan to dismantling Confederate monuments, George Orwell has been pressed into the service of all sorts of causes. But the real Orwell remains unknown.

Peter Ross

Forum

Being serious about equality means aiming to ensure we all live equally flourishing lives—not merely that we have the chance to do so.

Christine Sypnowich

A biography of Norman Bel Geddes, designer of the Futurama, tells the story of American innovation.

John Crowley
Fiction

This is my version of the story, but I will illuminate only a corner of it, one that ran parallel to and underneath it, revealing what was left in its wake.

Ian Maxton

What would it look like if we put our desires at the center of our politics?

adrienne maree brown

A rural town in Spain gives us a glimpse into the challenges we will face in a workless future.

David McDermott Hughes

Our weekly themed Reading Lists compile the best of Boston Review’s archive. Sign up for our newsletters to get them straight to your inbox before they appear online.

Boston Review is nonprofit and reader funded.

We believe in the power of collective reasoning and imagination to create a more just world. That’s why we’re committed to keeping our website free and open to everyone, regardless of ability to pay. But we can’t do it without the financial support of our readers.

Help sustain a public space for collective reasoning and imagination, without ads or paywalls:

Become a supporting reader today.

Get Our Newsletter

Sign up to get vital reading on politics, literature, and more sent straight to your inbox.

Most Recent

Jefferson Cowie speaks with Aziz Rana about whether the language of freedom can be taken back from its "sordid history" in the U.S. context.

Aziz Rana, Jefferson Cowie

While the U.S.–Israel alliance has become isolated, new ones are emerging.

Helena Cobban

After decades of deference to the market, states are exerting greater control over capital. In the face of climate change, it may be too little, too late.

Jonathan S. Blake

Jacob Hacker and Paul Pierson lead a forum on the transformation of the Democratic Party.

Plus essays on Zionism and geopolitics after October 7; poetry by Fady Joudah; and more.

Preorder now or become a member at any level to get it as your first issue.

Jacob Hacker and Paul Pierson lead a forum on the transformation of the Democratic Party—with responses from Ro Khanna, Lily Geismer, Dorian Warren, Heather Gautney, and others. 

Plus essays on Zionism and colonialism, Walter Rodney’s legacy, and geopolitics after October 7; poetry by Fady Joudah; and more.

Preorder now or become a member at any level to get it as your first issue.