Don’t Miss a Thing

Get our latest essays, archival selections, reading lists, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox.

Search Website
Sheryl Sandberg standing in front a big board showing Facebook's network of social connections

Sheryl Sandberg, Chief Operating Officer of Facebook, speaks at a Facebook event for marketing professionals in 2012. Image: AP Photo/Mark Lennihan

Reading List August 12, 2022

Privacy in the Age of Surveillance Capitalism

An “unholy alliance” of state and private industry threatens to undermine democracy and individual autonomy.

It has become commonplace to observe that privacy is a thing of the past and that we now live in an age of “surveillance capitalism.” But what precisely does this mean? Debates about privacy in recent years have focused on two trends: the post 9/11 surveillance state and the rise of the Internet.

As civil rights attorney and law professor Joseph Margulies explains, “9/11 launched the creation of the modern surveillance state”—epitomized by the NSA’s bulk collection of Americans’ data and phone records—and “narrowed our conception of privacy.” More disconcerting than the bare fact of ubiquitous surveillance, Margulies argues, is its normalization across the political spectrum, evident most recently in the the “stunning breadth” of the House Jan. 6 committee’s demand that social media companies share information related to “misinformation” and “domestic violent extremism.” “A meaningful fraction of the center left, no less than the right, aspires to round-the-clock surveillance of those they mistrust,” he notes.

As significant as these government incursions into privacy are, they may seem quaint when compared to the routine surveillance of our lives on the Internet, which is driven as much by the mundane commercial interests of advertisers as by the desire of the national security state to maintain access to our communications. As Evgeny Morozov presciently warns in his 2011 essay on privacy, the Internet, and advertising, an “unholy alliance between the highly customized advertising excesses of modern capitalism and the data-gathering excesses of the modern surveillance state” threatens to turn “everyday Internet users into law enforcement’s greatest ally.” The problem is not simply that we are being spied on but that we have been cajoled into spying on ourselves.

The challenges posed for democracy by today’s unprecedented erosion of privacy are serious, ranging from alleged attacks on dissidents and human rights advocates enabled by Israeli spyware to systematic campaigns of disinformation. According to philosopher Carissa Véliz, “The power that privacy grants us collectively as citizens is necessary for democracy—for us to vote according to our beliefs and without undue pressure, for us to protest anonymously without fear of repercussions, to have freedom to associate, speak our minds, read what we are curious about.” “Privacy is a public good,” she concludes “and defending it is our civic duty.”

What is to be done? In his lead essay for our 2014 forum on saving privacy, former FCC chairman Reed Hundt makes the case for a privacy bill of rights that revolves around the potential of encryption to create private digital spaces. Those skeptical that such an individualized framework can be effective might consider Aziz Huq’s suggestion that “collective ownership by cities is a way to seize back a measure of control over data’s destiny.” Meanwhile, Matthew Crain argues that one decisive step toward restoring privacy rights would be to pass the Banning Surveillance Advertising Act.

With additional essays and interviews that touch on radical attempts to redesign digital spaces in opposition to surveillance, the threat of punitive AI in the workplace, and the need to balance the right to privacy with public-spiritedness, this reading list offers resources with which we might respond to our current surveillance capitalist era.

Sheryl Sandberg standing in front a big board showing Facebook's network of social connections
Matthew Crain

Twenty-five years of neoliberal political economy are to blame for today’s regime of surveillance advertising, and only public policy can undo it.

Payton Croskey Kenia Hale Nate File

Younger voices are using technology to respond to the needs of marginalized communities and nurture Black healing and liberation.

Aziz Z. Huq

We need a model of ownership that recognizes our collective interests.

Sophia Goodfriend

In the high-tech culture of Tel Aviv, military-grade spying on civilians has become just another office job.

Joseph Margulies

Far from a relic of the past, September 11 continues to normalize state-sanctioned barbarity.

Stacked, open Amazon boxes with stuff in them
Andrea Dehlendorf, Ryan Gerety

The problems go beyond the abstractions of democracy and liberty. New workplace technologies cater to punitive practices that harm Black and brown people the most.

Carissa Véliz

The more someone knows about us, the more they can influence us. We can wield democratic power only if our privacy is protected.

simon-feature
William H. Simon

A little surveillance can do us a lot of good.

hundt---herten-feature
Reed Hundt

Framing surveillance as a tradeoff between privacy and security is a dead end for democracy.

Screen Shot 2019-03-18 at 3
Evgeny Morozov

By routinely giving away a huge amount of personal data, everyday Internet users might already have become law enforcement’s greatest ally.

Our weekly themed Reading Lists compile the best of Boston Review’s archive. Previews are delivered to members every Sunday. Become a member to receive them ahead of the crowd.

Boston Review is nonprofit and reader funded.

Contributions from readers enable us to provide a public space, free and open, for the discussion of ideas. Join this effort – become a supporting reader today.

Sign Up for Our
Newsletter

Vital reading on politics, literature, and more in your inbox. Sign up for our Weekly Newsletter, Monthly Roundup, and event notifications.

Donate Today!


Most Recent

Poetry

But I do miss the hymns, / the small, hard apples with their dimpled skin. I do miss / things.

Hannah Craig

The vast hinterlands of the Global South’s cities are generating new solidarities and ideas of what counts as a life worth living.

AbdouMaliq Simone

Protests in China are shining a light not only on the country’s draconian population management but restrictions on workers everywhere.

Eli Friedman