Help Us Stay Paywall-Free

We rely on readers to keep our website open to all. Help sustain a public space for collective reasoning and imagination—make a tax-deductible donation today.

The facade of Stonewall Inn with Pride flags waving above it.
Reading List June 26, 2023

Radical Pride

The rebellious origins of LGBTQ liberation

The origins of Pride Month lie in rebellion. On June 28, 1969, a routine police raid on the Stonewall Inn in Greenwich Village encountered fierce resistance from the bar’s patrons. Fed up with constant police harassment, the denizens of Stonewall—a diverse group of gay, lesbian, and trans people—decided to fight back. The spontaneous uprising sparked a wave of protests that helped catalyze the movement for LGBTQ liberation. 

Today, Pride Month is celebrated around the United States, but what has become of its radical legacy? According to historian Micki McElya, “the messy dynamism, diversity, and radical potential of Stonewall has been assimilated as an easy shorthand for the success of U.S. liberalism, with its inevitable (if hard-won) progress and inclusion.” Epitomized by Pete Buttigieg— a “moderate Democrat who embraces a particular species of Middle American wholesomeness”—Stonewall has been “recast” as “the origin of a centrist rights movement,” McElya contends. 

Diving into the history of radical gay liberation, veteran gay liberationist Michael Bronski notes that even the comparatively moderate and respectable Mattachine Society—a gay rights organization founded in the early 1950s—had Communist Party roots. The Gay Liberation Front and allied organizations that emerged in the wake of Stonewall “drew most of their members from the New Left,” Bronski writes. “Fueled by the enormous energy of the Black Power movement, the antiwar movement, and Second Wave feminism (as well as sex, drugs, and rock-and-roll), this iteration of gay activism demanded not rights but wholesale cultural change.” 

Other essays on this week’s reading list aim to revive the radical legacy of Stonewall while examining the tension between radical and reformist roads to LGBTQ rights. Drawing on the ideas of E. P. Thompson and Walter Benjamin, Samuel Clowes Huneke seeks a “usable” queer history in the everyday experiences of unsung heroes and activists; Hugh Ryan asks whether “homonormativity” has displaced gay liberation; Mary Bernstein wonders if the courts are the right arena in which to fight for queer rights; Joanna Wuest exposes the hollowness of corporate allyship; Joseph J. Fischel discusses police at Pride events; and more.

Micki McElya

The press has crowned Buttigieg the inheritor of Stonewall’s legacy, but this doesn’t square with what we know of Stonewall activists and the world they hoped to create.

Michael Bronski
Radical gay liberation laid the ground for the moderate legal gains of gay rights.
Samuel Clowes Huneke
In our search for a useful past, we need to be careful whom we name as the heroes of queer history.
Joseph J. Fischel
Pride festivities attempt every year to reinforce the idea of an LGBT community, but when it comes to views on policing, white gay men and trans women of color often have little in common.
Mary Bernstein

In the fight for LGBTQ equality, the law is often the last thing to change.

Joanna Wuest
Companies are unreliable allies in the fight for queer rights and social justice. We must rebuild a working people's movement.
Hugh Ryan

Did the success of gay marriage erode the radical potential of queer politics?

Samuel Clowes Huneke

The pandemic may spell the end of many gay bars, but apps and increased acceptance for LGBTQ people meant most were already on the rocks. Should we mourn their passing?

Jack Halberstam

Feminism and trans* activism have been at odds for decades. They don't need to be.

Michael Bronski
The death of Charley Shively marks the end of an era, but his revolutionary ideas for a just society resonate now more than ever.

Our weekly themed Reading Lists compile the best of Boston Review’s archive. Previews are delivered to members every Sunday. Become a member to receive them ahead of the crowd.

Boston Review is nonprofit and reader funded.

We believe in the power of collective reasoning and imagination to create a more just world. That’s why we’re committed to keeping our website free and open to everyone, regardless of ability to pay. But we can’t do it without the financial support of our readers.

Help sustain a public space for collective reasoning and imagination, without ads or paywalls:

Become a supporting reader today.

Sign Up for Our

Vital reading on politics, literature, and more in your inbox. Sign up for our Weekly Newsletter, Monthly Roundup, and event notifications.

While we have you...

Most Recent

To make change, movements need to build endurance—the capacity to keep people showing up despite their differences.

Mie Inouye

most days, during some mid-day hour, / I close my eyes and say the Sh’ma. / But it’s always the wrong time of day, / and it’s the only prayer I know

Matthew Lippman
Andrew Ross

Now’s the time to get our latest issue!

Until September 29, sign up for a print membership and get a copy of On Solidarity, plus four forthcoming issues—that’s 5 issues for the price of 4 (and 50% off the cover price)!

Use code FREECOPY at checkout.

Now’s the time to get our latest issue!

Until September 29, sign up for a print membership and get a copy of On Solidarity, plus four forthcoming issues—that’s 5 issues for the price of 4 (and 50% off the cover price)!

Use code FREECOPY at checkout.