Help Us Stay Paywall-Free

Democracy depends on the free exchange of ideas. Help sustain it with a tax-deductible donation today.

July 23, 2023

The Precarious State of Israeli Democracy

Putting Israel’s recent protests in context.

For months, Israeli protesters have assembled in massive numbers, motivated by opposition to judicial reforms proposed—and now partially enacted—by the current far-right government. Protesters say the reforms, which weaken courts’ power to review and strike down legislation, pose an existential threat to Israeli democracy. 

For progressives in the United States, the situation may appear puzzling. In recent years they have typically argued the opposite: the courts’ power must be reined in to prevent democracy from being undermined by “juristocracy,” rule by unelected judges. According to Jacob S. Abolafia and Jonathan S. Gould, however, whether the courts help or hinder democracy depends on context. In Israel, the “lawmaking system has many fewer veto points than the American one,” making the courts an essential check on the power of a legislature that “is less likely to protect the rights of minorities than the U.S. Congress.” In the U.S., on the other hand, “overly empowered courts further bog down a frustratingly veto-heavy legislative docket.” Given the differences between the two political systems, it makes sense that pro-democracy activists in each country would adopt opposed attitudes toward the role of the courts. 

Of course, talk of Israeli democracy is likely to seem rather hollow to Palestinians, whose subordinate status and lack of civil rights has been classified as apartheid by major human rights groups. To understand how Israel’s current far-right coalition came to rule, it is necessary not only to examine the demise of the Israeli peace movement and the rise of Kahanism—the racist ideology represented by Israel’s security minister Itamar Ben Gvir—but also to scrutinize the creation of the Israeli state itself, which took place against the backdrop of the Nakba, the violent expulsion and exodus of 750,000 Palestinians that occurred in 1948. Far from a one-time event, the logic of the Nakba continues to shape Israeli politics today. As Raja Shehadeh writes, “more than seventy years after the cataclysmic event, the Israeli army continues to pursue policies based on the denial of Palestinians as a national group entitled to self-determination, consequently violating their civil and human rights.” Israeli democracy ultimately depends on confronting this primal injustice and its ongoing consequences, which many protesters have been reluctant to acknowledge. 

In addition to these perspectives, this week’s reading list provides more essential context for understanding current events in Israel. In his review of Eric Alterman’s recent history of U.S.-Israel relations, We Are Not One, Jeremy Pressman explains how American Jews came to identify with Zionism and why, increasingly, they no longer do so; Noura Erakat, Aslı U. Bâli, and Omar Dajani describe efforts to think Palestinian liberation beyond the nation-state; Jennifer Zacharia discusses the IDF’s killing of her cousin, the Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, in Jenin, where IDF forces recently conducted further operations; Ariella Aïsha Azoulay examines the relationship between language and colonialism and shines a light on the construction of mizrahi Jewish identity; Joshua Abramson Cohen and Ezra Glinter show that Israel as it currently exists is only one, historically contingent, articulation of Jewish national aspirations; and more. 

On language and belonging.

Ariella Aïsha Azoulay

In Palestine and Kurdistan, promising experiments in self-determination draw on the region’s pluralist history.

Aslı U. Bâli, Omar Dajani

Palestinian women and feminist organizations are reimagining what liberation can look like beyond national independence.

Noura Erakat

The courts have become a flashpoint in the United States and Israel—but for very different reasons.

Jacob S. Abolafia, Jonathan S. Gould

The decline of Israel’s progressive movement.

Helena Cobban

They might, given growing disaffection with Israel among young American Jews.

Jeremy Pressman

Daniel Boyarin makes the seemingly paradoxical proposal that in order to end Zionism, Jewishness should be defined as nationhood.

Joshua Abramson Cohen

Alternatives to Zionism, from the Uganda Scheme to Birobidzhan, present a complex history of the search for a Jewish home.

Ezra Glinter

A Palestinian mother’s perspective.

Muzna Awayed-Bishara

Condemning U.S. deference to Israel, a cousin remembers the life and legacy of the slain Palestinian American journalist.

Jennifer Zacharia

Our weekly themed Reading Lists compile the best of Boston Review’s archive. Sign up for our newsletters to get them straight to your inbox before they appear online.

Boston Review is nonprofit and reader funded.

We believe in the power of collective reasoning and imagination to create a more just world. That’s why we’re committed to keeping our website free and open to everyone, regardless of ability to pay. But we can’t do it without the financial support of our readers.

Help sustain a public space for collective reasoning and imagination, without ads or paywalls:

Become a supporting reader today.

Get Our Newsletter

Sign up to get vital reading on politics, literature, and more sent straight to your inbox.

Most Recent

A Vietnam veteran on the political legacy of self-sacrifice and the necessity of war resistance.

David Cortright

Is there anything left to anti-imperial visions of global commerce?

Kate Yoon
Poetry

Who did this to you?

Sean Patrick Mulroy

"A tremendous resource in this time of chaos."

We publish leading scholars, activists, and writers on the most pressing political debates of our time.

But as a small nonprofit, we rely on reader support. Will you help support bold thinking about a more just world?

"An indispensable pillar of the public sphere."

That’s what sociologist Alondra Nelson says of Boston Review. Independent and nonprofit, we believe in the power of collective reasoning and imagination to create a more just world.

That’s why there are no paywalls on our website, but we can’t do it without the support of our readers. Will you make a tax-deductible contribution today?